Nutter Butter Recipes To Delight Your Taste Buds (2024)

Introduction

Are you up for the snack-time adventure? Nutter Butter is here to challenge your taste buds. This brand has been present since 1969 and has built a loyal fanbase. That’s why there’s a reason for the tagline that goes like, ‘The Peanut Butter Lover’s Cookie.‘ You can prepare unique cookie recipes, including milkshakes, pies, bars, truffles, brownies, etc. 

So, this blog will also unleash your inner cookie artist and help you sculpt your nutty masterpieces. Well, there’s no lousy settling for store-bought peanut cookies, especially when you don’t have time, but trying this homemade adventure once will reap something good and unique for your taste buds. And, yes, you’ll thank us later for the same!

Let’s unveil all the peanut spread bliss rolled just for you! 

What is Nutter Butter?

It’s an American brand owned by Nabisco and is like the rockstar of cookies in the snack world. The brand is known to prepare a delightful combination of smooth, creamy peanut spread sandwiched between two crunchy, peanut-shaped cookies. 

Whether you’re a peanut spread fanatic or just someone looking for a unique twist on the classic cookie, the brand brings a smile to your taste detectors. It’s fun, nutty, and the perfect companion for those moments when you need extra sweetness in your day.

They have the hero ingredient, ‘peanut spread,’ in the cookies and the creamy filling sandwiched between Nutter Butters. And this is a cookie that defies the ordinary with a peanut shape. Nevertheless, they can be found in a range of shapes today.

The brand uses natural peanut spread to prepare its cookies. Also, the classic ones are vegan-friendly. However, some of their offerings also contain dairy products. These cookies are one of the snack options of the American Red Cross. These cookies taste like a delicious fusion of crisp and rich flavors. Salt flakes are often added to the treat to kick it and make it stand out. By the way, this cookie is good for your health. you can consume it.

The Origins and Evolution of Nutter Butter

Let’s talk a bit about the brand’s history! This cookie company was established in 1969 and is held by The North American Biscuit Company commonly known as Nabisco. But no one knows who invented the peanut-shaped, dual-sided waffle pattern cookie design.

William Turnier, the former design engineer of Nabisco, is partly responsible for developing the signature look of waffle-pattern cookies. 

But Nabisco says it’s purely fictitious to accredit any individual for creating the unique design of cookies as it’s more of a team effort. Thus, the brand’s origins are in utter mystery right now! 

Those of you who grew up watching its commercials on TV may remember Nabisco’s infamous cartoons from the 1970s. A mascot from the brand offers cookies to kids on the playground in the commercials. (Watch it on YouTube). 

The brand launched its cookie-inspired cereal line in December 2017 by Post Consumer Brands. Then, cookie-twist doughnuts were released in October 2018 by Krispy Kreme. Following this, chocolate fudge-covered cookies also arrived in January 2019. 

7-Eleven began offering their limited edition lattes and doughnuts in 2019. During the same period, these cookies flavored milkshakes and Oreo-flavored ice creams at A&W Restaurants. In addition to other products, it was noted that cookies contributed to Mondelez’s sales growth throughout the year, even though it is one of their smaller brands.

How Popular is Nutter Butter?

This is a ‘Peanut spread Lover’s Cookie’ still famous among them. Although not all of its offerings are vegan, you can track down its popularity when one of the popular portals, Veg News, mentions this brand.

(Read the blog here!) According to the U.S. consumer survey 2020, as calculated by Statista, about 17.24 consumers have eaten 1-3 packages of these cookies within any span of 30 days. 

Their strong ties with blood donors might be the next factor behind their prominence. Besides the vending machines, you’ll surely find packages of Nutter Butter cookies at blood donation sites anywhere in America.

It even got a strong backlash from donors when cookie-freebies ended in the 1990s. 

Nabisco stopped supplying these cookies to the Red Cross after they mentioned they couldn’t afford them. Consequently, Nabisco had to face the negative PR as well. So, the company ultimately decided to offer these cookies freely to donation centers. 

‘Are you listening?’ is what their Instagram bio screams! So, the brand also has a quite strong presence on social media. Now, let’s talk about what’s more on ground zero! Nutter Butter are expensive cookies and might not be the best bang for your buck.

Yes, you heard it right—a package of 16oz. will cost you probably $4.68. That’s a lot if we compare it with certain other competitive brands.

Despite their premium price tag, these cookies captivate the hearts (and taste buds) of a dedicated following who recognize and savor their unparalleled richness. The exquisite blend of nutty goodness encased in each cookie is a symphony of flavors that transcends cost boundaries for some.

Nutter Butter Flavors

1. Wafers Cookie

These are crispy wafers with peanut butter creme. These are prepared by stacking the medium layers of crispy wafers and a rich peanut cream filling in between. Whether you’re looking for a quick snack or a delicious dessert, these wafers with peanut spreadr creme provide a satisfying and enjoyable experience for your taste buds.

2. Big Bag Bites

These little treats are bite-sized wonders that pack a punch of peanut spreadgoodness. Imagine tiny, circular discs, perfectly portioned to provide a quick and satisfying snack. The compact size allows them to be used for quick munching or sharing with others. Have a look at this recipe, and go for its cookie milkshake!

3. Nutter Butter Double Nutty Sandwich Cookies

Shaped like adorable peanuts, these double nutty sandwich cookies bring fun to snacking and appeal to all ages. What makes them stand out is that they boast twice the amount of this delectable nut spread filling, ensuring an extra burst of flavor in every bite.

4. Chocolate Fudge-Covered Cookies

These delightful treats take the classic cookies to a new level, enveloping them in a luscious layer of rich chocolate fudge. You’ll enjoy the perfect blend of peanut butter, crunchy cookies, and chocolate fudge’s rich, velvety goodness with every bite.

5. Nutter Butter Cakesters

Indulge in the delectable experience of soft-baked snack cakes expertly layered to ensure you savor the exceptional premium peanut butter filling nestled within. Each bite is a delightful balance of softness and nutty goodness, making these cakes a delightful snack for any occasion. These casters are giving a strong competition to Oreo casters. (How? See here!)

Baking Peanut Cookies at Home

Yayy! It’s cookie-baking time. Grab your apron and channel your inner cookie connoisseur because today, we’re diving into the world of peanut butter perfection! It doesn’t matter what shape you bake them in.

Let’s dive into the step-by-step instructions as defined below!

Prepare the Nutter Butter cookies

Source

 

Step 1: Make a creamy mixture by beating the granulated sugar and peanut butter together. 

Step 2: Add a little amount of vanilla extract and eggs into the mixture and beat them until thoroughly mixed.

Step 3: Shape them into small balls using about half to 1 teaspoon of mixture for each ball.

Step 4: Take a prepared baking sheet and set the dough balls together on it. Then, flatten the cookies to a thickness of ⅛ to ¼ inch.

Step 5: Create criss-cross markings on the dough’s surface with the fork’s tines.

Step 6: Bake these Nutter Butter cakesters cookies in a preheated oven for about 9 to 11 minutes.

Step 7: Once baked, allow the cookies to cool completely before enjoying your homemade peanut butter delights.

Make a peanut butter filling

Source

Step 1: You’re just a step away from preparing this yummy filling. Take peanut butter, maple syrup, powdered sugar, and vanilla syrup. Beat them all together! Mix some milk or maple syrup if it becomes too thick. Blend some powdered sugar if it becomes too thin.

It’s time for a sandwich assembly!

Source

Step 1: Place and spread the filling on one of the cookies and stack them with the filling nestled within. Place these sandwiched Nutter Butter cookies on the parchment-lined baking sheet and transfer them to a freezer for about 10 minutes.

Finish with extra touches (Optional)

Source

Step 1: You can turn it into chocolate fudge cookies by melting the chocolate. Simply melt the chocolate, dip the cookies in it, sprinkle some sea salt flakes, and let it set up entirely before completing. 

Freeze the cookies!

Step 1: If you don’t want to freeze, store them at room temperature in a sealed enclosure for up to 4-5 days. Flash-freeze them for 30 minutes by laying the cookies on a single-line baking sheet. Once they’re frozen, keep them in an enclosed container.You can keep them in the freezer for up to three months. 

With this last step, you’re good to go!

Top 05 Nutter Butter Recipes

Nutter Butter Bars

Source

List of Ingredients Required:

• Unsalted butter (softened)
• Light brown sugar
• Creamy peanut butter (Jif or Skippy recommended)
• Large egg
• Semi-sweet chocolate chips
• Nutter Butter cookies

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Prepare dry ingredients

Blend the peanut butter cookies into small to medium-sized pieces in a food processor. Combine baking soda, regular flour, and salt in a bowl.

Step 2: Beat butter and sugars

Prepare a creamy blend of brown sugar, softened butter, and regular sugar in a bowl. Beat, beat & beat!

Step 3: Add wet ingredients

Combine the vanilla extract and nut spread into the butter and sugar blend created in the step above—mix by adding the egg on medium speed. Finally, With a rubber spatula, remove the sides of the vessel.

Step 4: Add flour mixture

 Ensure that the cookie dough reaches the corners of an 8×8-inch square pan. Then, add chopped Nutter Butter and chocolate chips into the blend.

Step 5: Press cookie dough

Press the cookie dough into an 8×8-inch square pan, ensuring it reaches the corners.

Step 6: Bake

Bake until the edges turn golden for approx. 20-25 minutes. Ensure the middle is set to avoid underbaking. Add finishing touches to the bar with chopped cookie flakes and cool them on a rack before removing them from the pan. 

Watch Video For Better Understand

Nutter Butter Pie

Source

List of Ingredients & Equipment Required:

• Salted butter
• Marshmallow fluff or creme
• Cream cheese
• Cool whip
• Creamy nut spread
• Peanut butter sandwich cookies
• Food processor
• Electric mixer (either hand-held or stand mixer)

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Prepare a good blend of salted butter and crumbled cookies on a pie plate. Press them enough!

Step 2: Bake this mixture in an oven for 12-15 minutes at 350 degrees. Then, cool them down!

Step 3: Take marshmallow fluff, peanut spread, and cream cheese and beat them up.

Step 4: Fold 10-12 crushed peanut spread sandwich cookies and cool whip them into half.

Step 5: Transfer this enriched filling into pie crust. Then, spread the cool whip evenly on the top of the crust and end this yummy treat process by refrigerating them.

Nutter Butter Milkshake/Protein Shake

Source

List of Ingredients & Equipment Required:

• 1 cup ice
• ½ cup skimmed milk
• One scoop of protein powder
• One tablespoon vanilla pudding mix (sugar-free)
• Nutter Butter bites or mini cookies
• One tablespoon of peanut spread powder
• One tablespoon of whipped cream
• Blender

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Take a blender and mix milk, protein powder, ice cubes, and sugar-free pudding mix until the texture becomes creamy and smooth.

Step 2: Combine and mix one tablespoon of water and peanut spread.

Step 3: Drizzle the above mixture of peanut spread on the shake and garnish it with mini Nutter Butter cookies and whipped cream.

Note: You can add peanut butter powder to the blender above using vanilla protein powder. 

Peanut Butter Cookie Brownies

Source

List of Ingredients Required:

For Chocolate Brownie Frosting

• One tablespoon of cocoa powder
• 1/4th cup butter
• 1.5 cups of powdered sugar
• 2.5 tablespoon of milk

For Brownie

• Two eggs
• 25 sandwich cookies made with nut butter
• One box of Brownie mix
• ½ cup of vegetable oil

For Toppings

• 12 nut butter cookies
• 1-2 tablespoons of peanut butter

Step-by-Step Instructions

General Instructions

Step 1: Preheat your oven to 350°. Get a 9*9 baking ready by lining it with parchment paper or applying a generous non-stick cooking spray.

For Brownies

Step 2: Combine brownie mix, eggs, and oil in a bowl thoroughly. Do it either manually or using a hand mixer.

Step 3: Spread 2/3 of the batter in the pan. Place 25 mini Nutter Butter cookies on top. Over the cookies, drizzle the remaining 1/3 of the batter.

Step 4: Bake for approx. 35-40 minutes. Let it cool completely after taking it from the oven.

For Chocolate Brownie Frosting

Step 5: Light a small saucepan at medium heat and combine melt butter, cocoa powder, and milk. Now, take it off, and mix powdered sugar, whisking until smooth. Spread the frosting evenly over the brownies.

For Toppings

Step 6: While the frosting is still wet (act swiftly), drizzle melted peanut butter on top. Use dental picks to make a decorative pattern.

Step 7: Press 12 mini peanut butter cookies onto the brownies and gently press down. Let the frosting set before cutting it into 12 squares. Serve or store these brownies in an airtight container for up to 4 days.

Nutter Butter Truffles

Source

List of Ingredients Required:

• 8 oz softened cream cheese
• 16 oz peanut butter cookies package
• 10 oz chocolate melting wafers
• 1/4th cup powdered sugar
• 1/4th cup creamy nut butter
• Sea salt (for topping)
• Sprinkles (for topping)
• Optional 1/4th tsp salt

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Make fine crumbs of nut butter cookies in a food processor.

Step 2: Now, mix nut butter, cream cheese, and sugar into the processor. Add salt as per your taste, which is optional.

Step 3: Take a medium cookie scoop to form a mixture into balls. Place them on a parchment-lined sheet.

Step 4: Melt wafers in a bowl at 30-second intervals, stirring until smooth.

Step 5: With a spoon and fork, dip each ball in chocolate, then slide it off the fork onto parchment paper to set. Just before the chocolate sets, sprinkle on Nutter Butter crumbs or sea salt.

Step 6: To make them firmer, let them sit in the fridge for 10 minutes or at room temperature for 30 minutes. For up to two weeks, store them in an airtight container in the refrigerator.

FAQs

1. Is Nutter Butter real peanut butter?

Its peanut spread is prepared with roasted peanuts, hydrogenated vegetable oil, corn syrup solids, salt, and peanut oil.

1. Why are these peanut spread cookies so hard to find?

In 2022, Supply Chain Dive published an article stating that the lack of key ingredients is one of the major reasons for the intermittent stockout of these products at grocery stores. 

1. How many calories in a Nutter Butter?

A 25g serving size of cookies provides 120 calories in total.

1. What are peanut butter cookies by Mondelez International made out of?

The key ingredients used to prepare these cookies include nut butter, unbleached enriched flour, sugar, soybean/canola oil, high fructose corn syrup, whole grain wheat flour, palm oil, soy lecithin, salt, leavening, and some artificial flavors.

1. Does the same company make Nutter Butter and Oreos?

Yes, the main company of both products is the same, i.e., Mondelez International.

Conclusions

Whether you’re a seasoned baker or a beginner baking guy, our diverse collection of recipes ensures there’s a Nutter Butter delight for every taste preference. So, seize the opportunity to indulge in the nutty goodness, and let the joy of crafting and savoring these scrumptious creations become a highlight of your culinary adventures.

It’s time to elevate your snack game, share the love, and relish the sweet moments! Hope you like this amazing recipe. if you do like it then must share it with your friends and family.